Car park claims dominate for women while men make a big impact


The age old debate over whether men or women are better drivers may never be resolved, however new research can confirm one thing, they definitely crash differently.

Car insurance specialist Diamond has studied data from over 400,000 accident claims over the last five years and found there are differences between the types of crashes men and women have.

Women are more likely than men to hit a parked car, have a collision in a car park and reverse into a vehicle. On the other hand, men are more likely to hit an animal, hit a crash barrier and run up or down an embankment.

The list of accidents more common with women than men is dominated by low impact collisions such as having an accident when pulling from a parked position. Whereas the accidents most common with men include more high impact crashes such as hitting a tree, having a head-on collision with another vehicle and having a multi car shunt.

Diamond managing director, Dave Halliday, commented, “We were interested to investigate the types of accident claims made by men and women to see if there were any differences. It’s clear that on the whole women are more likely to have low impact collisions at lower speeds in places such as car parks, whereas men are more likely to have more destructive accidents at higher speeds.”

“Accidents caused by men are on average more costly than those caused by women. This was why in the past women paid lower insurance premiums than men. It’s a month since the EU Gender Directive came in and our research clearly shows there are differences between men and women.”

Types of claims more common among women than men

Hit parked and unattended vehicle
Collision in a car park
Reversed into a vehicle
Accident when driving out of a minor road
Accident when pulling from a parked position
Hit a wall
Hit stationary vehicle
Collision on a roundabout
Accident when turning across another vehicle’s path
Hit another vehicle

Types of claims more common among men than women

Hit an animal
Hit a crash barrier
Ran down/up an embankment
Hit a tree
Hit a pedestrian on the pavement
Head on collision with another vehicle
Multi car shunt
Policyholder hit a motorcyclist
Narrow lane collision
Policyholder changed lanes and hit a vehicle

In fact, it isn’t just accidents where men and women motorists differ. There are differences when it comes to other types of claim too; overall men are more likely to have their car stolen, suffer flood damage, have something stolen from their car and claim for fuel contamination.

Dave continued, “Men are more likely to claim for flood damage, which includes driving through a flood, and for putting the wrong fuel in their car. This could suggest that men are more careless than women.”

Share with your friends

Help us improve our website

Is our website easy to use? Does it have all the information you need? Tell us what you think.

Please note, whilst we value your feedback and review it on a regular basis, we do not reply directly to comments submitted via this form.

If you have feedback on our other services or need assistance in any other way, please go to our secure form.

Errors on form:

Your details

Tell us what you think

Thank you

Thank you for your feedback on our website

Tell us what you think...